Can incorporating genotyping data into efficacy estimators improve efficiency of early phase malaria vaccine trials?

Abstract Background Early phase malaria vaccine field trials typically measure malaria infection by PCR or thick blood smear microscopy performed on serially sampled blood. Vaccine efficacy (VE) is the proportion reduction in an endpoint due to vaccination and is often calculated as VEHR =1 – hazard ratio or VERR = 1 – risk ratio. Genotyping information can distinguish different clones and distinguish multiple infections over time, potentially increasing statistical power. This paper investigates two alternative VE endpoints incorporating genotyping information: VEmolFOI, the vaccine-induced proportion reduction in incidence of new clones acquired over time, and VEC, the vaccine-induced proportion reduction in mean number of infecting clones per exposure. Methods We used simulations and analytic derivations to compare power of these methods to VEHR and VERR and applied them to three data sets: a Phase 3 trial of RTS,S malaria vaccine in 6912 African infants, a Phase 2 trial of PfSPZ Vaccine in 80 Burkina Faso adults, and a trial comparing Plasmodium vivax incidence in 466 Papua New Guinean children after receiving chloroquine + artemether lumefantrine with or without primaquine (as these VE methods can also quantify effects of other prevention measures). By destroying hibernating liver-stage P. vivax, primaquine reduces subsequent reactivations after treatment completion. Results The RTS,S vaccine significantly reduced the number of clones at first infection, but PfSPZ vaccine and primaquine did not. Resampling smaller data sets from the large RTS,S trial to simulate phase 2 trials showed modest power gains from VEC compared to VEHR for data like RTS,S, but VEC is less powerful than VEHR for vaccines which do not reduce the number of clones at first infection. VEmolFOI was most powerful in model-based simulations, but only the primaquine trial collected enough serial samples to precisely estimate VEmolFOI. The primaquine VEmolFOI estimate decreased after most control arm liver-stage infections reactivated (which mathematically resembles a waning vaccine), preventing VEmolFOI from improving power. Conclusions The power gain from the genotyping methods depends on the context. Because input parameters for early phase power calculations are often uncertain, we recommend against these estimators as primary endpoints for small trials unless supported by targeted data analysis. Trial registrations: NCT00866619, NCT02663700, NCT02143934.

Medienart:	Preprint

Erscheinungsjahr:	2023
Erschienen:	2023

Enthalten in:	ResearchSquare.com - (2023) vom: 25. Dez. Zur Gesamtaufnahme - year:2023

Sprache:	Englisch

Beteiligte Personen:	Potter, Gail E. [VerfasserIn] Callier, Viviane [VerfasserIn] Shrestha, Biraj [VerfasserIn] Joshi, Sudhaunshu [VerfasserIn] Dwivedi, Ankit [VerfasserIn] Silva, Joana C. [VerfasserIn] Laurens, Matthew B. [VerfasserIn] Follmann, Dean A. [VerfasserIn] Deye, Gregory A. [VerfasserIn]

Links:	Volltext [lizenzpflichtig] Volltext [kostenfrei]

Themen:	570 Biology

doi:	10.21203/rs.3.rs-3370731/v1

funding:
Förderinstitution / Projekttitel:

PPN (Katalog-ID):	XRA04100583X