Serially Combining Epidemiological Designs Does Not Improve Overall Signal Detection in Vaccine Safety Surveillance

Introduction Vaccine safety surveillance commonly includes a serial testing approach with a sensitive method for ‘signal generation’ and specific method for ‘signal validation.’ The extent to which serial testing in real-world studies improves or hinders overall performance in terms of sensitivity and specificity remains unknown. Methods We assessed the overall performance of serial testing using three administrative claims and one electronic health record database. We compared type I and II errors before and after empirical calibration for historical comparator, self-controlled case series (SCCS), and the serial combination of those designs against six vaccine exposure groups with 93 negative control and 279 imputed positive control outcomes. Results The historical comparator design mostly had fewer type II errors than SCCS. SCCS had fewer type I errors than the historical comparator. Before empirical calibration, the serial combination increased specificity and decreased sensitivity. Type II errors mostly exceeded 50%. After empirical calibration, type I errors returned to nominal; sensitivity was lowest when the methods were combined. Conclusion While serial combination produced fewer false-positive signals compared with the most specific method, it generated more false-negative signals compared with the most sensitive method. Using a historical comparator design followed by an SCCS analysis yielded decreased sensitivity in evaluating safety signals relative to a one-stage SCCS approach. While the current use of serial testing in vaccine surveillance may provide a practical paradigm for signal identification and triage, single epidemiological designs should be explored as valuable approaches to detecting signals..

Medienart:	E-Artikel

Erscheinungsjahr:	2023
Erschienen:	2023

Enthalten in:	Zur Gesamtaufnahme - volume:46
Enthalten in:	Drug safety - 46(2023), 8 vom: 16. Juni, Seite 797-807

Sprache:	Englisch

Beteiligte Personen:

Arshad, Faaizah [VerfasserIn] Schuemie, Martijn J. [VerfasserIn] Bu, Fan [VerfasserIn] Minty, Evan P. [VerfasserIn] Alshammari, Thamir M. [VerfasserIn] Lai, Lana Y. H. [VerfasserIn] Duarte-Salles, Talita [VerfasserIn] Fortin, Stephen [VerfasserIn] Nyberg, Fredrik [VerfasserIn] Ryan, Patrick B. [VerfasserIn] Hripcsak, George [VerfasserIn] Prieto-Alhambra, Daniel [VerfasserIn] Suchard, Marc A. [VerfasserIn]

Links:	Volltext [kostenfrei]

Anmerkungen:	© The Author(s) 2023

doi:	10.1007/s40264-023-01324-1

funding:
Förderinstitution / Projekttitel:

PPN (Katalog-ID):	OLC2144460116