Physiologic Adaptation to Macronutrient Change Distorts Findings from Short Dietary Trials : Reanalysis of a Metabolic Ward Study
Copyright © 2023 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved..
An influential 2-wk cross-over feeding trial without a washout period purported to show advantages of a low-fat diet (LFD) compared with a low-carbohydrate diet (LCD) for weight control. In contrast to several other macronutrient trials, the diet order effect was originally reported as not significant. In light of a new analysis by the original investigative group identifying an order effect, we aimed to examine, in a reanalysis of publicly available data (16 of 20 original participants; 7 female; mean BMI, 27.8 kg/m2), the validity of the original results and the claims that trial data oppose the carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity (CIM). We found that energy intake on the LCD was much lower when this diet was consumed first compared with second (a difference of -1164 kcal/d, P = 3.6 × 10-13); the opposite pattern was observed for the LFD (924 kcal/d, P = 2.0 × 10-16). This carry-over effect was significant (P interaction = 0.0004) whereas the net dietary effect was not (P = 0.4). Likewise, the between-arm difference (LCD - LFD) was -320 kcal/d in the first period and +1771 kcal/d in the second. Body fat decreased with consumption of the LCD first and increased with consumption of this diet second (-0.69 ± 0.33 compared with 0.57 ± 0.32 kg, P = 0.007). LCD-first participants had higher β-hydroxybutyrate levels while consuming the LCD and lower respiratory quotients while consuming LFD when compared with LFD-first participants on their respective diets. Change in insulin secretion as assessed by C-peptide in the first diet period predicted higher energy intake and less fat loss in the second period. These findings, which tend to support rather than oppose the CIM, suggest that differential (unequal) carry-over effects and short duration, with no washout period, preclude causal inferences regarding chronic macronutrient effects from this trial.
| Medienart: |
E-Artikel |
|---|
| Erscheinungsjahr: |
2024 |
|---|---|
| Erschienen: |
2024 |
| Enthalten in: |
Zur Gesamtaufnahme - volume:154 |
|---|---|
| Enthalten in: |
The Journal of nutrition - 154(2024), 4 vom: 04. Apr., Seite 1080-1086 |
| Sprache: |
Englisch |
|---|
| Beteiligte Personen: |
Soto-Mota, Adrian [VerfasserIn] |
|---|
| Links: |
|---|
| Themen: |
Body composition |
|---|
| Anmerkungen: |
Date Completed 15.04.2024 Date Revised 15.04.2024 published: Print-Electronic Citation Status MEDLINE |
|---|
| doi: |
10.1016/j.tjnut.2023.12.017 |
|---|
| funding: |
|
|---|---|
| Förderinstitution / Projekttitel: |
|
| PPN (Katalog-ID): |
NLM366195379 |
|---|
| LEADER | 01000caa a22002652 4500 | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 001 | NLM366195379 | ||
| 003 | DE-627 | ||
| 005 | 20240415233043.0 | ||
| 007 | cr uuu---uuuuu | ||
| 008 | 231227s2024 xx |||||o 00| ||eng c | ||
| 024 | 7 | |a 10.1016/j.tjnut.2023.12.017 |2 doi | |
| 028 | 5 | 2 | |a pubmed24n1376.xml |
| 035 | |a (DE-627)NLM366195379 | ||
| 035 | |a (NLM)38128881 | ||
| 035 | |a (PII)S0022-3166(23)72806-X | ||
| 040 | |a DE-627 |b ger |c DE-627 |e rakwb | ||
| 041 | |a eng | ||
| 100 | 1 | |a Soto-Mota, Adrian |e verfasserin |4 aut | |
| 245 | 1 | 0 | |a Physiologic Adaptation to Macronutrient Change Distorts Findings from Short Dietary Trials |b Reanalysis of a Metabolic Ward Study |
| 264 | 1 | |c 2024 | |
| 336 | |a Text |b txt |2 rdacontent | ||
| 337 | |a ƒaComputermedien |b c |2 rdamedia | ||
| 338 | |a ƒa Online-Ressource |b cr |2 rdacarrier | ||
| 500 | |a Date Completed 15.04.2024 | ||
| 500 | |a Date Revised 15.04.2024 | ||
| 500 | |a published: Print-Electronic | ||
| 500 | |a Citation Status MEDLINE | ||
| 520 | |a Copyright © 2023 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. | ||
| 520 | |a An influential 2-wk cross-over feeding trial without a washout period purported to show advantages of a low-fat diet (LFD) compared with a low-carbohydrate diet (LCD) for weight control. In contrast to several other macronutrient trials, the diet order effect was originally reported as not significant. In light of a new analysis by the original investigative group identifying an order effect, we aimed to examine, in a reanalysis of publicly available data (16 of 20 original participants; 7 female; mean BMI, 27.8 kg/m2), the validity of the original results and the claims that trial data oppose the carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity (CIM). We found that energy intake on the LCD was much lower when this diet was consumed first compared with second (a difference of -1164 kcal/d, P = 3.6 × 10-13); the opposite pattern was observed for the LFD (924 kcal/d, P = 2.0 × 10-16). This carry-over effect was significant (P interaction = 0.0004) whereas the net dietary effect was not (P = 0.4). Likewise, the between-arm difference (LCD - LFD) was -320 kcal/d in the first period and +1771 kcal/d in the second. Body fat decreased with consumption of the LCD first and increased with consumption of this diet second (-0.69 ± 0.33 compared with 0.57 ± 0.32 kg, P = 0.007). LCD-first participants had higher β-hydroxybutyrate levels while consuming the LCD and lower respiratory quotients while consuming LFD when compared with LFD-first participants on their respective diets. Change in insulin secretion as assessed by C-peptide in the first diet period predicted higher energy intake and less fat loss in the second period. These findings, which tend to support rather than oppose the CIM, suggest that differential (unequal) carry-over effects and short duration, with no washout period, preclude causal inferences regarding chronic macronutrient effects from this trial | ||
| 650 | 4 | |a Journal Article | |
| 650 | 4 | |a body composition | |
| 650 | 4 | |a clinical trial | |
| 650 | 4 | |a insulin | |
| 650 | 4 | |a low-carbohydrate diet | |
| 650 | 4 | |a low-fat diet | |
| 650 | 4 | |a macronutrients | |
| 650 | 4 | |a methodology | |
| 650 | 4 | |a obesity | |
| 650 | 7 | |a Insulin |2 NLM | |
| 650 | 7 | |a Dietary Carbohydrates |2 NLM | |
| 700 | 1 | |a Jansen, Lisa T |e verfasserin |4 aut | |
| 700 | 1 | |a Norwitz, Nicholas G |e verfasserin |4 aut | |
| 700 | 1 | |a Pereira, Mark A |e verfasserin |4 aut | |
| 700 | 1 | |a Ebbeling, Cara B |e verfasserin |4 aut | |
| 700 | 1 | |a Ludwig, David S |e verfasserin |4 aut | |
| 773 | 0 | 8 | |i Enthalten in |t The Journal of nutrition |d 1945 |g 154(2024), 4 vom: 04. Apr., Seite 1080-1086 |w (DE-627)NLM000006300 |x 1541-6100 |7 nnns |
| 773 | 1 | 8 | |g volume:154 |g year:2024 |g number:4 |g day:04 |g month:04 |g pages:1080-1086 |
| 856 | 4 | 0 | |u http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tjnut.2023.12.017 |3 Volltext |
| 912 | |a GBV_USEFLAG_A | ||
| 912 | |a GBV_NLM | ||
| 951 | |a AR | ||
| 952 | |d 154 |j 2024 |e 4 |b 04 |c 04 |h 1080-1086 | ||